[R] Best way to tackle this ICML vague response?

Reddit - Machine Learning 1 min read

About this article

Going through ICML submission for the first time. I had a reviewer ask for some things and during the rebuttal period I ran more experiments and answered all their questions (they wrote 3 weaknesses). Yesterday started the author-reviewer discussion period which ends on April 7. In their response to my rebuttal the reviewer wrote in one line that my "experiments greatly improved the paper" but "some details remain only partially clarified". That's it... They marked "Acknowledgement: (b) Parti...

You've been blocked by network security.To continue, log in to your Reddit account or use your developer tokenIf you think you've been blocked by mistake, file a ticket below and we'll look into it.Log in File a ticket

Originally published on April 02, 2026. Curated by AI News.

Related Articles

Machine Learning

I am doing a multi-model graph database in pure Rust with Cypher, SQL, Gremlin, and native GNN looking for extreme speed and performance

Hi guys, I'm a PhD student in Applied AI and I've been building an embeddable graph database engine from scratch in Rust. I'd love feedba...

Reddit - Artificial Intelligence · 1 min ·
Llms

Chatgpt vs purpose built ai for cre underwriting: which one can finish the job?

I keep seeing people recommend chatgpt for financial modeling and I need to push back because I spent a month testing it for multifamily ...

Reddit - Artificial Intelligence · 1 min ·
UMKC Announces New Master of Science in Artificial Intelligence
Ai Infrastructure

UMKC Announces New Master of Science in Artificial Intelligence

UMKC announces a new Master of Science in Artificial Intelligence program aimed at addressing workforce demand for AI expertise, set to l...

AI News - General · 4 min ·
[2512.02966] Lumos: Let there be Language Model System Certification
Llms

[2512.02966] Lumos: Let there be Language Model System Certification

Abstract page for arXiv paper 2512.02966: Lumos: Let there be Language Model System Certification

arXiv - AI · 4 min ·
More in Machine Learning: This Week Guide Trending

No comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!

Stay updated with AI News

Get the latest news, tools, and insights delivered to your inbox.

Daily or weekly digest • Unsubscribe anytime